
“A House of Repentance” (Beginnings - 1880)
Episode 1 | 1h 38mVideo has Audio Description
Some colonists argue that public punishments make “bad men worse” and look for an alternative.
Europeans bring their harsh laws to America, but some colonists, inspired by the Enlightenment, argue that brutal public punishments make “bad men worse” and look to a new way to mete out justice – the penitentiary.
See all videos with Audio DescriptionADProblems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Episodes presented in 4K UHD on supported devices. Major funding for CRIME AND PUNISHMENT IN AMERICA was provided by The Atlantic Philanthropies, Emerson Collective, The Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, and...

“A House of Repentance” (Beginnings - 1880)
Episode 1 | 1h 38mVideo has Audio Description
Europeans bring their harsh laws to America, but some colonists, inspired by the Enlightenment, argue that brutal public punishments make “bad men worse” and look to a new way to mete out justice – the penitentiary.
See all videos with Audio DescriptionADProblems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch Crime and Punishment in America
Crime and Punishment in America is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Measuring Crime and Punishment
How does the way we collect and measure crime shape our understanding of it? Crime statistics can tell us how crime changes over time. But the way crime is measured, defined, and communicated can also shape public perception and policy.Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipAnnouncer: Major funding for "Crime and Punishment in America" was provided by... The Atlantic Philanthropies, Emerson Collective, The Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, and the Park Foundation.
Major funding was also provided by the following members of The Better Angels Society: The Fullerton Family Charitable Fund, The Just Trust for Education, Allan and Shelley Holt, The Tow Foundation, and the Sozosei Foundation.
Additional support was provided by the National Endowment for the Humanities, The Arthur Vining Davis Foundations, and by The Better Angels Society members: John and Catherine Debs, Timothy Fazio, Lise Strickler and Mark Gallogly, the Laurie M. Tisch Illumination Fund, and these additional funders.
"Crime and Punishment in America" was made possible, in part, by contributions to your PBS station from Viewers Like You.
Thank you.
Viewer discretion is advised.
The following program contains content which may not be suitable for all audiences.
♪ Voice: I, Levi Ames, was born in Groton, in New England, of a credible family.
My father died when I was but two years old.
I am the first of the family who was ever disgraced.
My prevailing sin was thieving.
I began by stealing a couple of eggs, then a jack-knife, after that some chalk.
I stole a gun from Josiah Richardson and a large silver spoon from one Mr.
Howard.
I robbed the Rev.
Mr.
Clark of a tankard, 12 tea-spoons, and two pair of sugar tongs.
I thought to repent and reform; but found myself powerfully urged to repeat this wickedness, by the temptations of the devil.
[Levi Ames] Narrator: In 1773, when Levi Ames was 21 years-old, he was found guilty of burglary for the third time and sentenced to death.
While he was held in jail awaiting execution, printers produced 18 different versions of his confession, selling and reselling his story to a public fascinated by tales of crime and punishment.
Jen Manion: At its most basic level, it was entertainment.
Public statements from the person who was going to be executed were often some of the most popular publications in the Colonial Era, and executions were some of the largest public gatherings.
There's a very good chance that most people witnessed a public execution in their lifetime.
We, today, watch television shows and read books that are all about crime and punishment.
We're no different, you know, than people from the Colonial Era.
Narrator: On the day Levi Ames was to be executed, some 8,000 people converged on the city of Boston to watch him hang.
Voice: I am now made to feel the anger of God against me.
God will not let disobedient children pass unpunished.
May God forgive me my dreadful wickedness.
[Levi Ames] Stephen Breyer: The human condition is a difficult condition.
The way things used to work 10,000 years ago is you lived in little groups, and someone came from behind a rock, and you didn't recognize him.
The only wise thing to do was kill him immediately because he might kill you, and gradually, there has been the development of a civilization away from that kind of thing and not perfectly, either, by any means.
♪ Franklin D. Roosevelt: A prison to us is no longer a Bastille to keep people in indiscriminately, and our object ought to be to turn them out as better citizens than when they went into prison.
J. Edgar Hoover: The Federal Bureau of Investigation is waging a relentless warfare against crime and criminals.
Newsreel narrator: The king of the gangsters is about to be taken for a ride by your Uncle Samuel.
William Parker: You see, crime in America is skyrocketing.
It is not a question of the proficiency of the police.
It's a question of the indulgences of the American people.
Get your hands up, I said.
Drop that purse and get your hands up.
LD Barkley: We are men.
We are not beasts, and we do not intend to be driven or beaten as such.
Doris Tate: We must fight for victims' rights, and we know the victims have no rights.
Speaker: The crime rate isn't going down.
Violent crime was up 10% across the country last year.
Ronald Reagan: We must make America safe again.
It's time to get these hardened criminals off the street and into jail.
Speaker: How do you ask somebody to forgive you for something that is almost impossible to forgive?
Bill Clinton: When you commit a third violent crime, 3 strikes, and you are out.
Bill Bratton: I'm sensing a fear among American police forces that we are losing the streets.
Reginald Dwayne Betts: Everybody says, "Why'd you do it?"
But we never have reasons, never good ones.
♪ Narrator: The problem of crime is as old as civilization itself.
Every tribe, every religion, every society has created laws and determined punishments for those who broke them.
The ancient Babylonians inscribed their Code of Hammurabi in stone.
The Aztecs depicted their laws in the Mapa Quinatzin.
The Tang Dynasty in China decreed a Great Code of Abominations.
Muslims established Sharia Law; Hindus, the Laws of Manu; Jews and Christians, the 10 Commandments.
Khalil Gibran Muhammad: We can think of these as the basic building blocks of a society, and for most of human history, the basic ingredients of accountability and justice was reminding a person of their shared duty and obligations to their fellow human beings.
The point of these rules is to help us to live together in peace and perhaps, in the most idyllic sense, harmony for the purposes of sharing the resources of a community that we have.
Rafael A. Mangual: There are certain people who cannot be trusted to, on their own, live according to the rules that we know would allow society to function in the best way possible.
Hobbes had it right.
If all men were angels, no government would be necessary.
This is sort of one of those universal recognitions and why almost every society that's ever existed in human history has had some form of governing structure to constrain that human instinct for domination, predation going back to Hammurabi's Code, right, you know, and an eye for an eye.
Narrator: The promise of justice has almost always been inseparable from the demand for punishment, which has been used to shame, to deter, or to satisfy the human desire for revenge.
[Gunshots, soldiers shouting] A few years after Levi Ames was put to death for burglary, Americans waged a revolution and created a new nation with a new form of government.
To address the problem of crime, Americans would develop a new system of punishment.
Instead of being whipped, shamed, or executed in the public square, people who broke the law would be sent to prisons and penitentiaries, where they were expected to repent and return to society reformed.
Incarceration as both punishment and rehabilitation was something no country had ever tried.
Heather Ann Thompson: We tend to think about our whole nation's history in terms of progress, in terms of liberty, justice, freedom, all of these really positive, wonderful qualities, but at the same time, to keep some measure of order, some measure of safety, we have become really consumed with practices of punishment.
We need to understand how these principles can co-exist.
What do they have to do with one another?
[Metal door shuts] Narrator: For 250 years, Americans would argue about the root cause of crime and the purpose of punishment.
Laws would change.
Prosecutors, judges, and the courts would adapt.
Constables, militias, and watchmen would be replaced by armed, uniformed police.
Guns would proliferate.
So would drugs, so would poverty, and so would bloodshed.
Despite the public's fascination with outlaws, fear of violent crime would become one of the most potent forces in American life.
By the dawn of the 21st century, with less than 5% of the world's population, the United States would account for more than 20% of the incarcerated people on Earth.
James Forman Jr.
: When I think about crime and punishment in America, I think that it says that we are a very unforgiving country.
It's tempting to want to find one moment, one president, one act of Congress, right, one motivation and say, "Well, that explains the whole thing," but, in fact, the way we got to this system was in 50 states, in 3,000 counties, a series of actors, most of them unknown to us, made small decisions in the direction of harshness, in the direction of punitiveness.
This is another area where America is exceptional.
It's just not exceptional in the way that we want to be.
♪ [Heavy object scraping] [Indistinct voices on P.A.]
[Door buzzer sounds] Betts: What does it mean to be accountable?
I went to prison at 16.
I was trying to survive prison.
When was I supposed to find time to figure out what it meant to-- to be accountable?
You know, it's like you... you dig a hole in the ground and then you spend the rest of your life trying to fill that hole... [Indistinct chatter] but how do you quantify that and how do you admit that you got to rebuild something that you had a hand in destroying?
The hardest thing to admit is that you did a wrong and you have no solution for fixing it.
[Rumbling] ♪ [Man singing in Indigenous language] Voice: My kinsmen, a great wrong has been done to us.
We have been outraged and caused to weep without shame, men though we are.
So of course it would be right for us to go out and do to the murderer what he has done to our loved one.
Antelope.
Narrator: For thousands of years, long before European settlers arrived in North America, the continent's Native nations administered justice according to their own traditions.
Depending on the severity of the offense, those who broke the rules could be reprimanded by tribal elders, commanded to apologize, to make reparations, to undergo a cleansing ceremony, or they could be banished.
N. Bruce Duthu: If someone did go off the tracks, there were likely reasons, maybe deep in the structure of that family, in the way that that family nurtured this individual, or perhaps didn't, so the question is really, what did we all do that may have contributed to this disruption, this rupture of the peace in our community, and how do we collectively atone for that?
Narrator: To restore the peace, different nations had different approaches.
Among the Dakota people, if one member of the tribe murdered another, a male relative of the victim was expected to kill the murderer.
If no one relative was willing to act, the tribal council decreed that all the men in the family would impose the punishment together.
Voice: It was a solemn day.
Men, women, and children thronged about, for this was something everyone dreaded both to see and to miss seeing.
The relatives of the slain man were required to shoot, thus all inflicting together the punishment that none would undertake alone, and then the murderer was down, with as many arrows sticking into his back as his victim had male relatives.
[White Horse] Narrator: The Dakota had another way of responding to homicide, but it was almost never undertaken.
Instead of seeking vengeance, the victim's family would agree to adopt the man who had wronged them.
Voice: On the appointed day, the leading men of the tribe and the relatives assembled in the council tipi; soon, the speaker was saying, "Smoke now, with these, your new kinsmen, "for they have decided to take you to themselves in place of the One-who-is-not-here."
[White Horse] Bryan Stevenson: What you saw, in many Indigenous communities was this evolving notion that restorative justice can sometimes be healthier for a community than retributive justice, that is, the idea that you do harm to the person who's done harm to you can create a lot of resentment and ongoing-- it doesn't resolve some of the tensions, where restorative justice is very much rooted in the idea that we want resolution.
We want to all move forward toward healing; we want to limit further harm, not just be prepared to punish more harm.
Voice: Killing would only take an instant, and it would be simple, but it would not end the hate.
To win the murderer by kinship and kindness was the surer way.
How proud must their murdered kinsman have been, looking backward from Ghostland and seeing what they were doing!
[Antelope] ♪ Voice: If any person shall commit burglary, such person shall for the first offense be branded on the forehead with the letter B, and if any person shall commit burglary on the Lord's day, he shall have one of his ears cut off, and if he shall fall into the like offense the third time, he shall be put to death.
The Charters and General Laws of the Colony and Province of Massachusetts Bay.
[People shouting, whip cracks] Narrator: When Europeans arrived in America, they brought their forms of justice with them.
Colonists accused of crimes were held in jail until their cases were resolved.
If they were found guilty, they were punished harshly and in public.
Mangual: The idea was to satiate their desire for justice to be done, and if the government fails to meet that moral standard that is widespread throughout society, what happens is that the society will then take the law into their own hands, but also, by doing these things in public, it could help maximize the deterrent impact.
Imagine seeing somebody hang.
That is absolutely going to have an impact in terms of, you know, people committing a criminal offense.
They might then see that and say, "OK, well, I'm--I'll think twice about that."
Narrator: Throughout the colonies, rape, treason, and murder were punishable by death, and so were many other crimes: forgery, adultery, aiding runaway slaves, stealing horses, and witchcraft... [Fire crackling] but by the time of the Revolution, many Americans had come to see brutal public punishments as a symbol of the tyranny they were determined to overthrow.
In declaring their independence from England, America's founders promised to establish a government that would recognize and protect the inalienable rights of man.
Breyer: "We hold these truths to be self-evident, "that all men are created equal, "that they are endowed by their creator with certain "inalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness."
There it is.
In a sentence.
In a sentence.
Basic beliefs in this document that underlies, at least in theory, and not always in practice, but at least in theory, how we want this country to be seen and to be run.
Narrator: The new nation, John Adams said, must have a "government of laws, and not of men," where all had the right to be treated fairly and impartially.
♪ Mangual: Our country was founded by virtue of it getting fed up with an oppressive monarchy that had too much power.
It was taxation without representation.
It was people having just soldiers show up at their house and search without any warrants, so everything built into our structure is designed to make sure that the overarching government does not ultimately have, you know, soul-crushing power over the citizenry.
Narrator: After lengthy negotiations, the Constitution of the United States was enacted in 1789.
It was the result of many compromises, including whether slavery would be allowed to continue and the balance between state and federal powers.
Each state retained the authority to write its own criminal laws and establish punishments for breaking them.
The "Bill of Rights," 10 amendments that were added to the Constitution, protected Americans' right to speak and worship freely and the right to keep and bear arms.
Anyone accused of federal crimes would have "due process of law," an impartial jury, and the "assistance of counsel" for their defense.
They could not be subjected to "excessive bail" or fines or "cruel and unusual punishments."
Stevenson: I do think that the greatness of America was our ability to articulate a vision of democracy, a vision of a just society that created for every individual a commitment to fairness and equality and justice, and that remains at the core of what makes America this exciting idea in the minds of so many.
Of course, we very quickly failed to honor those ideas by what we were doing.
Duthu: We know that when the Constitution uses the first 3 words of the Preamble, "We the people," for every "We," there's an excluded "They."
Women were not included, Native Peoples were not included, African Americans were not included, so one has to hold dear to the idea that this was the beginning, it was not the end point.
Rebecca McLennan: I think the revolutionary generation got a lot of things wrong, but they were really energized by the Enlightenment, and they saw themselves as at the forefront of human history.
They were extremely committed to this moral project of doing something that had never been done before, and also, they had a narcissistic self-confidence that basically you could perform a surgery on the souls of men.
♪ Voice: An attachment to kindred and society is one of the strongest feelings in the human heart.
A separation from them, therefore, has ever been considered as one of the severest punishments that can be inflicted upon man.
Personal liberty is so dear to all men that the loss of it for an indefinite time is a punishment so severe that death has often been preferred to it.
Benjamin Rush.
Narrator: Many believed the new nation should develop a more enlightened system of justice, where the punishment would be proportional to the crime.
No American was more concerned with questions of crime and punishment than the Philadelphia reformer Dr.
Benjamin Rush.
A signer of the Declaration of Independence, he was an advocate for women's education and a pioneer in the treatment of mental illness.
He was one of the first Americans to argue that public punishment didn't work.
Voice: The reformation of a criminal can never be effected by a public punishment.
A man who has lost his character at a whipping-post has nothing valuable left to lose.
I shall take the liberty of declaring that public punishments tend to make bad men worse and to increase crimes.
Benjamin Rush.
Caleb Smith: There were huge crowds at these events.
These become scenes of riot and disturbance, and the public's capacities for sympathy get pulled in the wrong ways, things get disordered.
You know, if--to be deterred, I have to identify with the person who did this thing and say, "If I do the same thing he did, I'll be put to death," but I might also start identifying with him in other kinds of ways, right, or the violence itself might be exciting and contagious, and that's why we need to move punishment out of the public square and behind closed doors.
Voice: Let it not be supposed that I wish to abolish punishments.
Far from it.
I wish only to change the place and manner of inflicting them.
Let a large house be erected in a remote part of the state.
Let its doors be of iron and let the grating, occasioned by opening and shutting them, deeply pierce the soul.
Let all the officers of the house be strictly forbidden ever to discover any signs of mirth or even levity in the presence of the criminals.
To increase the horror of this abode of discipline and misery, let it be called by some name that shall import its design, a "house of repentance."
[Benjamin Rush] Narrator: Inspired by Benjamin Rush's idea of a house of repentance, Pennsylvania decided to turn a section of Philadelphia's squalid, overcrowded jail into the Walnut Street Prison.
Other countries had prisons-- the Bastille in France, England's Tower of London-- but they held political prisoners.
The Walnut Street Prison would be something new.
It was to be a place of punishment and penitence for ordinary people who broke the law.
It was the world's first penitentiary.
McLennan: It's not like no one's ever been held against their will before.
It's not like we haven't had workhouses before, but that's to pay off a debt.
What we haven't had before is incarceration as punishment for crime.
Narrator: The Walnut Street Prison opened its doors in 1790.
Most men and women held there were convicted of property crimes.
During the day, they toiled together in workshops so they could learn "habits of industry."
Mangual: The penitentiary represented a real kind of win for reformers in society.
The religious ideal was that everyone has an inherent capacity for redemption that needs to be recognized.
Prisons were actually a humane response to how we were doing justice up until that point.
Manion: It sounds more progressive.
It sounds like an improvement on what was... and then there's the reality.
[Indistinct chatter, footsteps] Voice: I will now give you some information of the general situation of the interior of this penitentiary, so celebrated for its humanity.
The cells are constructed over the common sewer, from which there is a flue leading to each apartment.
That at once accounts for the numerous deaths and ruined constitutions of the unfortunate inhabitants, who for the most trifling fault, are hurried into these abominable receptacles for 30, 60, and 90 days with one miserable blanket for their covering and an allowance of 3 ounces of brown bread for 24 hours.
Ann Carson.
Narrator: Ann Carson, who had been sent to the Walnut Street Prison after being found guilty of robbery, published one of the first accounts of life there.
The penitentiary she described was as squalid as the jail it had replaced.
Many of the prisoners showed no sign of repentance or reform.
They refused to work, gambled, drank, rioted.
Some even managed to escape and terrorize the city.
♪ In 1821, the state of Pennsylvania decided to replace Walnut Street with a massive new prison several miles from the city center, the Eastern State Penitentiary.
It was one of the most expensive public buildings in the nation, and it was built for one lofty goal: helping men and women repent and reform through solitary confinement.
Behind its 30-foot high walls, 7 cell blocks radiated from one central core.
The novel architecture of the building was specific to its purpose.
Perfect seclusion required that each 8-by-12-foot cell be equipped with running water, a flush toilet, and central heating, amenities even President Andrew Jackson did not yet have in the White House.
Each cell was lit by a skylight and a barred door leading to a tiny walled yard.
Meals were delivered through a slot in the wall.
Only one book was permitted--the Bible.
Prisoners were permitted to pass the time making shoes or weaving baskets, and were allowed into their yard for one hour a day.
They were never to see or speak to each other.
Whatever the length of their sentence, they would serve their time at Eastern alone.
Voice: Separate confinement is intended to furnish the criminal with every opportunity for promoting his restoration to the path of virtue because seclusion is an essential ingredient in moral treatment.
Philadelphia Society for Alleviating the Miseries of Public Prisons.
[Roberts Vaux] Betts: I mean, they say solitary was for you to repent, but one of the questions is, like, how and what are the mechanisms?
And If you leave somebody in absolute silence and you haven't been equipped to deal with your mind, I don't think that that's gonna be effective.
[Heavy scraping] [Keys jingling] ♪ Rahsaan Thomas: When you first get to the hole, I think that was the hardest time I've ever done, even though it's the safest 'cause you're in solitary, you're by yourself.
But there was absolutely nothing for my mind to do.
I swear to God, one hour felt like 6 days.
I would keep asking, "What time is it?"
And the time would not move, right?
It was just the most boring thing to be stuck with your thoughts, just be stuck having to face yourself.
No distractions, no nothing.
It's a form of torture.
It's like dropping water on your head.
It seems like it wouldn't hurt, but it's torturous.
You end up being released worse than you went in.
[Heavy scraping] [Tools scraping dirt] [Singers humming] Voice: The plantation was a little nation of its own, having its own language, its own rules, regulations, and custom.
The law and institutions of the state apparently touch it nowhere.
The troubles arising here are not settled by the civil power of the state.
The overseer is generally accuser, judge, jury, advocate, and executioner.
Frederick Douglass.
Narrator: In the eyes of the law, the men, women, and children held in bondage were considered property with no legal protections.
Muhammad: Over 90% of the Black population was enslaved, and for those who were enslaved persons, when there was some allegation of criminality, it was often dealt with in a form of plantation justice, either immediate corporal punishment, sometimes dismemberment and death.
Voice: The whites, having made us so wretched by subjecting us to slavery, and having murdered so many millions of us in order to make us work for them, strip and beat us one before the other, chain, hand-cuff, and drag us about like rattlesnakes, shoot us down like wild bears.
They, the whites, know well if we are men that there can be nothing in our hearts but death alone for them.
David Walker.
Narrator: Slaveholders lived in fear that those they enslaved would rise up, as they had again and again.
"That we deprive them of the sacred Boon of Liberty," the governor of Mississippi said, "is a crime they can never forgive."
To prevent the enslaved from rebelling or running away, Southern whites formed militias, town guards, and slave patrols, who searched slave quarters for weapons and stolen goods and roamed the countryside and city streets looking for runaways.
Whenever they left the plantation, slaves were required to carry a pass or wear a badge.
Slave patrols arrested and punished anyone they found without one.
Simon Balto: Part of what the slave patrols were charged with doing was surveilling enslaved people and free Black people, as well, to try to ensure that there were not any plots afoot, that there was not any rebellion being planned, that people were not, you know, managing to get their hands on guns.
Voice: I do swear that I will, as searcher for guns, swords, and other weapons among the slaves in my district, faithfully and as privately as I can discharge the trust reposed in me as the law directs.
So help me God.
Slave Patroller's Oath.
[North Carolina, 1828] Stevenson: You know, you had 10 million Black people who were enslaved for 246 years.
You would not be able to sustain an institution like that without the constant threat of violence, and when you look at the laws that were created to maintain that condition of servitude, they were all violent, but I think the greatest evil of slavery in America was the narrative we created to justify enslavement.
Because people who enslaved other people didn't want to think of themselves as immoral or indecent or unchristian, and so we created this false narrative where we said that Black people aren't as good as white people, that Black people are less evolved than white people.
♪ Forman: Slavery taught us and it taught the nation to think about Black people as scary.
It taught the nation to think of Black people as dangerous, as lawbreaking.
Well, if a country teaches itself for hundreds of years that Black people are dangerous, that Black people are criminal, that Black people are scary, that Black people don't feel pain, that Black people don't care about their children, those beliefs aren't going to go away quickly.
♪ [Birds chirping] Voice: Mr.
Superintendent, Dear Sir-- I am a colored man and live in the city of Rochester, New York.
I was sent to the New York House of Refuge up in the Bowery.
My number was 1221.
I am now writing a history of my life and what I have been through since I left the Refuge.
Will you please do me the kindness as to look over some of your old record books and see if you can find my name in any of them?
My name is Austin Reed.
Narrator: Austin Reed was born in 1823 and grew up in a community of free Black people in Rochester, New York.
His father, a successful barber, died when Reed was 6.
His mother could not afford to take care of him and sent him to a wealthy family's farm as an indentured servant.
Separated from his mother, mourning his father, Austin was homesick and lonely.
When he refused to eat or do his chores, the owner of the house whipped him.
Smith: He did not take well to this, especially to being punished, or, as he put it, "treated like a slave," and he eventually attempted to burn down the house of his master.
For this, he was sent to New York's House of Refuge when he was 10 years old.
Narrator: The House of Refuge in Lower Manhattan was the nation's first institution dedicated to what was called the "reformation of juvenile delinquents."
Smith: Most of the children are from recently immigrated Irish families, although there's a number of children of color there, as well.
Narrator: Life in the Refuge was strictly regimented.
The children's time was spent in school, in workshops, or in chapel.
Voice: I had been there nearly a year before I could learn all the little rules and regulations of the House.
First, that I must not talk in the shop, that I must not look behind me in the dining room, nor in the chapel, nor in the school room.
I had such a greedy appetite for reading that I was called up before Mr.
Williams, the schoolteacher, one day and laid across the stool, where I got 15 cuts with the rattan for having more than one book in my desk.
[Austin Reed] Narrator: Children who broke the rules were punished harshly with solitary confinement, handcuffs, and a whip made from strands of waxed cord, the cat-o-nine-tails.
[Whip cracks] Voice: Then was the worst days that ever I seen.
The superintendent began punishing the boys on the bare back every day with the cats.
It leaves a deep cut in the back, causing the tender skin to burst while the blood flows freely, leaving the back entirely striped with red.
[Austin Reed] Narrator: In 1839, 6 years after Reed arrived there, part of the Refuge burned to the ground.
Reed later wrote that some of the children had set the fire.
At 16, he was released.
Voice: I was at the outside of my mother's cottage door after being absent from home for 6 years and 7 months.
Heavens, heavens, I see the wrinkled face of my mother by the light of the pale empress of the night.
Let me go and find a lone and a silent place to weep.
Let darkness cover me till I approach the cottage door again with these scalding tears that's running from my eyes again.
[Austin Reed] ♪ [Footsteps] Voice: I do not believe in a complete reform except with young delinquents, but convicts can become useful citizens, having learned in prison a useful art and contracted habits of constant labor.
This is the only reform which I ever expected to produce, and I believe it is the only one which society has a right to expect.
Elam Lynds.
Narrator: Like Pennsylvania, the state of New York had turned to captivity as an alternative to public punishment.
Auburn, the state's monumental prison, had opened in 1818.
Elam Lynds, a veteran of the War of 1812, was put in charge, and he implemented a strict regimen of efficiency, order, and control.
The prison would be run according to Lynds' system for the next 100 years.
McLennan: Elam Lynds was the principal keeper, which means basically the head guard at Auburn Prison.
He's the prisons' first brutal bureaucrat, and to him the task fell of what to do with the prisoners by day, how to organize them.
His job is not to worry himself about the end goal or that there's a kind of moral goal here.
His job is simply a means job-- get the job done-- and the job is containing and controlling prisoners.
[Group marching] Narrator: Lynds insisted the men march in a rigidly synchronized human chain, the lockstep.
They wore striped uniforms that made them conspicuous if they managed to escape.
At all times, they were forbidden to speak.
Two dozen women were confined at Auburn, as well.
Lynds locked them away in a crowded, airless attic above the kitchen, gave them some sewing to do, delivered food once a day, and rarely allowed them outside.
Women were only ever 1% or 2% of the total population of incarcerated people through the 19th century.
They were incarcerated for prostitution, for petty theft, but also for having murdered their abusive husbands.
Manion: Authorities did not know what to do with women.
The system has no capacity, you know, to handle them.
It doesn't want them there, it's not built for them, so they were often put in a space that wasn't even a proper cell because they weren't just gonna throw them onto a floor that was full of men.
[Heavy scraping] [Door buzzer sounds] [Cell door shuts] Angelica Zaragoza: My first time going to prison, it was so lonely... [Indistinct chatter] full of fear of the unknown.
It is literally cages on top of cages, where you have 5 or 6 women in each one.
There's no circulation.
There's no daylight.
It is gloomy.
It is ugly.
It is hot.
When I was pregnant and 3 times bigger than my normal body, I still was expected to sleep on this thin mat.
Feminine products are scarce.
There were times that I've seen women tear up their clothes to use as hygiene products because they didn't have any choice.
There's not accommodations for us women inside of there.
The prisons were made for men.
[Heavy scraping] [Hammering] Voice: If you have once completely curbed the prisoner under the yoke of discipline, you may, without danger, employ him in the labor which you think best.
It is in this manner that the state may make use of the criminals in a thousand ways.
Elam Lynds.
Narrator: At Auburn, the men were forced to work 10 hours a day, 6 days a week in prison shops run by private contractors.
Some local businesses complained that unpaid prison labor gave their competitors an unfair advantage, but the state saw no reason to change the system.
The revenue generated by Auburn's workshops nearly offset the cost of operating the prison.
McLennan: The question of who's gonna pay for incarceration has been a lively question and has been debated since the beginning of the house of repentance.
It was based on a moral critique of offenders.
They should not be allowed a free ride, and taxpayers most certainly should not have to be paying for these dishonest, disreputable people to be maintained.
So the answer was incarcerated people are gonna pay for the cost of their own incarceration through labor, and we will sell the labor to private contractors.
Narrator: If any prisoners refused to work or broke the rules, they were whipped by the keepers.
[Whip cracks] Voice: I consider punishment by the whip the most efficient and, at the same time, the most humane which exists.
It never injures health and obliges the prisoners to lead a life essentially healthy.
I consider it impossible to govern a large prison without a whip.
Those who know human nature from books only may say the contrary.
[Elam Lynds] Narrator: New York authorities were so pleased with Lynds' innovations at Auburn that they asked him to oversee the construction of a new prison some 30 miles up the Hudson River from New York City.
To build it, Lynds brought 100 prisoners from Auburn.
It took them 3 years to construct the massive fortress where they would be locked away.
Sing Sing opened in 1826.
Timothy Gilfoyle: The cells in Sing Sing were extremely small, roughly 7 feet high, 8 feet long, 4 feet wide, with an iron door.
There's no heat, no wash basin.
There might be a little chamber pot, a Bible, a bed that's two feet wide that folded down from the wall.
Stephen B. Walker: There's nothing in normal society that replicates what a prison looks like.
It's like claustrophobia and someone forcing you to get over your fear by locking you into a closed setting every day.
It's mostly concrete and steel, brick, rock.
There's very little grass.
The intentional design of these systems is to convey a sense of punishment, of deprivation.
Narrator: Sing Sing would soon hold more than 900 men and a handful of women.
They were to "have no intelligence concerning relatives or friends," Elam Lynds said.
They were to be "buried from the world."
As the United States expanded westward, prisons sprang up from Maine to Missouri.
They quickly filled, mostly with poor, young white men, many of them immigrants.
Most prisons were modeled on the New York system of private contractors and forced labor pioneered by Elam Lynds, but all were seen as evidence of American ingenuity.
Prisons were written up in guidebooks, and sightseers were encouraged to visit them for 25 cents a tour.
Manion: In the early national period, these are the largest, grandest, most architecturally sophisticated buildings, and the penitentiary system was something that the United States was proud of.
McLennan: Every major European country sends observers to the United States to inspect Auburn Prison and sometimes Sing Sing and Eastern Prison and then write a report on whether this newfangled Republican institution could be adapted to the Western European context.
Narrator: France sent two young aristocrats, Gustave de Beaumont and Alexis de Tocqueville.
They visited prisons and jails from Boston to New Orleans.
They spent time with Elam Lynds at Sing Sing and were astonished by the sight of 900 unshackled men watched by just 30 keepers.
They attributed the prison's discipline to the law of silence and the lash.
Voice: It must be acknowledged that this penitentiary system in America is severe.
Whilst society in the United States represents the most extended liberty, the prisons of the same country offer the spectacle of the most complete despotism.
The citizens subject to the law are protected by it; they only cease to be free when they become wicked.
Alexis de Tocqueville.
Narrator: Despite their reservations, they recommended that France establish a penitentiary system based on the American example.
Smith: They produced a quite elegant philosophy of what these institutions were about, the transfer of punishment from the body to the soul.
They see this as much more effective than the kinds of institutions that they know about and certainly preferable to them than, let's say, the guillotine.
Narrator: When the celebrated British writer Charles Dickens toured the United States in 1842, he spent a day at Eastern, curious to see the prison's unique system of perpetual isolation.
[Cell door shuts] Voice: In its intention, I am well convinced that it is kind, humane, and meant for reformation; but I am persuaded that those who devised this system of prison discipline do not know what it is that they are doing.
The quiet that prevails is awful.
Every prisoner is a man buried alive; to be dug out in the slow round of years; and in the meantime, dead to everything but torturing anxieties and horrible despair.
I hold this slow and daily tampering with the mysteries of the brain to be immeasurably worse than any torture of the body because its wounds are not upon the surface, and it extorts few cries that human ears can hear.
Therefore, I the more denounce it, as a secret punishment which slumbering humanity is not roused up to stay.
Charles Dickens.
♪ [Indistinct chatter] Voice: All Europe is coming across the ocean; all that part at least who cannot make a living at home; and what shall we do with them?
They increase our taxes, eat our bread, and encumber our streets, and not one in 20 is competent to keep himself.
Mayor Philip Hone.
Narrator: By the 1840s, hundreds of thousands of European immigrants were arriving in America every year, crowding into the nation's rapidly growing cities.
Many of them were desperately poor Irish Catholics, whom native-born Protestants derided as "Paddies," short for the popular Irish name Patrick.
Voice: The vice of drunkenness among the lowering laboring classes is growing to frightful excess, and the multitudes of low Irish Catholics restricted by poverty in their own country run riot in this.
As long as we are overwhelmed with Irish emigrants, so long will the evil abound.
John Pintard.
Narrator: In Philadelphia, Boston, New York, and other cities where immigrants were settling, ethnic tensions frequently exploded into riots.
When mobs of Protestant nativists attacked Catholic churches, schools, and homes, local militias had to be called in to restore order.
Since colonial times, neighborhood watchmen and constables had patrolled the nation's streets, but as cities became unruly and chaotic, many Americans demanded something they had previously opposed: an organized police presence.
Gilfoyle: There was a sentiment that cities and communities should be policed by their own citizens, and there was a great resistance to any kind of policing force or military force in American communities going back really to the Boston Massacre in 1770.
There was always resistance to organized police forces, associating them with centralized arbitrary authority.
Narrator: In 1844, New York created the nation's first police department.
Within a generation, nearly every American city would have one of its own.
Voice: Their costume is a sure guarantee that they will never disgrace it; they know that they are known by it and, therefore, while they are watching others, that they are watched themselves.
They take good care, therefore, not to do any acts which will disgrace their uniform.
James Gerard.
Mangual: As urban life grew and you had lots of people congregating in small areas, where they were offered a sense of anonymity that didn't really exist in rural America, and so that changed when we urbanized as a country, right, because now you could pickpocket, you could snatch a purse and run into a crowd and get lost and get away with things, and that created a demand: "I don't want to have to police myself.
"I don't want to have to guard my belongings at all times."
Narrator: In New York, many of the men and women arrested were taken in for public drunkenness, and most of them were Irish.
The horsedrawn carts officers used to bring them to the station became known as paddy wagons.
As Irish immigrants gained a foothold in America, they also gained political power, winning control of urban Democratic political machines like New York's Tammany Hall.
McLennan: Tammany Hall started as a political organization and gradually became an organization committed to incorporating Irish immigrants into its operations so that they can vote and support the election of Tammany Hall Democrats.
In return for helping get out the vote and voting, you get jobs.
Narrator: Among the most coveted jobs Tammany Hall politicians offered their constituents-- in exchange for regular payoffs-- were positions in the New York City Police Department.
McLennan: There's no civil service.
This is how it worked.
If Tammany Hall wins City Hall, they take over the police department and are able to appoint their folks, so that is how Irish Americans, or at least a section of Irish Americans, are able to move through Tammany Hall into driving the paddy wagon rather than--heh-- being forced into it.
Narrator: Police were called upon to do many tasks.
McLennan: If you lose your children or if your children run away or if you need a place to sleep on bone-numbingly cold winter nights.
Animal control.
There's a rabid dog running down Broadway.
There's no such thing as animal control.
You have to call the police.
Narrator: At first, policemen were not issued guns, but as more and more Americans acquired firearms, police would begin to carry them, as well.
[Indistinct police radio chatter] ♪ Bratton: I was on the streets of Boston after 8 weeks of academy with a gun, a nightstick, a badge, the power to stop you, question you, arrest you, use force against you if appropriate.
We're authorized to actually take a life in certain circumstances.
In some respects, we have even more authority than just about any other entity in government, and at the same time, we're probably one of the most poorly trained entities in government to exercise those great powers.
The average cop gets 6 months of training.
In some jurisdictions, it's less than that, and oftentimes, it ends up in the stories that are so commonplace of police having to use force, sometimes deadly force, and nobody wins in that situation.
[Indistinct police radio chatter] [Heavy scraping] [Horse neighing, hoofbeats] Voice: After getting fairly settled at home and seeing all my friends, I made my way to the city, and studying the rule of vice and crime, I became a well-educated scholar, sinking my hands deeper and deeper in all kinds of crimes until I got so bold that I wasn't afraid to commit the blackest deed that was ever committed.
Austin Reed.
Narrator: 5 months after Austin Reed returned home, he was arrested.
When a customer at a brothel was robbed of $100 and Reed was caught gambling with some of the stolen bills, he was charged with larceny and taken to jail.
[Gavel bangs] Voice: With handcuffs on my wrists, I made my way to the courthouse.
I pled guilty to the whole charge and sat there awaiting to hear my doom.
The judge ask me if I had anything to say, why the sentence of the law should not be pronounced upon me.
I told him that I had nothing to say.
[Austin Reed] Smith: When he goes to trial, he lies about his age because he's so terrified to go back to the House of Refuge, and he knows that if he's a juvenile, that's where he's gonna be sent, so he would rather go to this place he doesn't know about than to the--the place whose violence he really does know.
♪ Narrator: The judge sentenced Reed to two years' hard labor to be served at Auburn.
Voice: I hardly seen a new face.
There were over 150 that I was well acquainted with: Jack Williams and Thom Payne, Joe Coutler and Harry Williams, Willie Jones and Charlie Kendell, all once little villains and scamps with me in the House of Refuge that gone through the same treatment that I had gone through and now had come forth into the world and followed the high roads of vice and crime.
[Austin Reed] Narrator: It did not take Reed long to learn the rules.
Voice: When marching, we must keep close together with our arms folded and our heads to the right, our heads bowed and our eyes a-looking down upon the ground.
Must not look up off of your work and cast an uplifted eye at spectators.
They came through to gaze and stare at us, and not we at them.
[Austin Reed] Narrator: One of the men incarcerated with Reed was Charles Plumb, who had been sent to Auburn at 19 for stealing a horse.
A man who had known Plumb before he went to prison called him "insane."
Smith: To have some kind of mental disability-- This is not a treatment facility, you know.
It's an industrial prison where everyone has to live by the same code.
Narrator: One day, Plumb walked away from his work assignment, ignored the keepers' commands, ran through the cell block, and shattered a window.
On orders from the warden, Plumb was whipped repeatedly.
Smith: Charles Plumb is not regulating himself in accordance with the institution's ideal of kind of militaristic self-discipline, and he receives this extreme punishment as if they could whip the wildness out of him.
Narrator: The next day, the keepers whipped him again for tearing up his Bible.
Plumb developed a fever, and a few days later, he died.
Voice: How is it under what is generally considered as the most benevolent system of the age a lad who only a few days before was blessed with the most robust health is a lifeless corpse!
Had this crime been committed in Rhode Island or any other state where the "brutal" system of the "public whipping post" is retained, he would probably have been punished to the extent of some 30 or 40 blows, and the law would have been satisfied.
"Auburn Journal."
Narrator: Charles Plumb's death caused such an uproar that New York's legislature banned prisons from using the lash, but keepers were allowed to use a machine that simulated drowning, called the showering bath, along with many other punishments.
[Heavy scraping] [Indistinct chatter] Get those cells right away.
[Officers speaking indistinctly] Step inside your cell, sir.
Walker: When I went into corrections, I had no real conceptual understanding of what the job was.
What they maybe unwittingly were instilling in us was that these are prisoners, they're not people.
If you don't recognize the value of another human being, it is easy to be overly aggressive.
It is easy to be inhumane.
[Officer speaking indistinctly] It was about custody and control.
[Heavy scraping] [Officer speaking indistinctly] Voice: In that day when I shall stand before God, I'll show him my back where the tyrant has printed it with the cats.
Those who might have done me a heap of good turned to be my destroyers, and the high and noble mind which God had given me have all been destroyed by hard usage and a heavy club.
The very prayers which my mother printed upon my lips have all been wash away beneath the waters of a showering bath.
[Austin Reed] Narrator: Time and again, Austin Reed disobeyed the rules and ignored the keepers' commands.
Time and again, they punished him, noting every infraction in their daily log.
Smith: Some of his transgressions we could hardly imagine being kind of violations of law or rules.
They include simply communicating with another inmate because there was supposed to be a rule of absolute silence, but some of them were quite rebellious.
He set a fire in one of the workshops.
He made threats against the lives of some of the guards.
He fought against them, and so on.
So he really was in defiance and in rebellion, and for that, he was made to suffer again and again and again.
Narrator: For two decades, Austin Reed cycled in and out of prison.
2 or 3 years behind bars, then a few months of freedom, and then he would be convicted of yet another property crime.
When he was released for the last time, Reed was 43 years old and had spent most of his adult life behind bars.
While he was in prison, he had managed to write a memoir, "The Life and the Adventures of a Haunted Convict."
Voice: Hard, hard indeed is the convict's allotment.
In silence he sits and thinks on the scenes of his boyhood, or in misery he paces his lonely cell, a-brooding on vice and crime.
With a broken heart he lays his drooping head down on his pillow at night, a-thinking whether he'll ever return from those gloomy walls back home to his friends alive.
Weeks rushes on, and he dies the death of a demon.
He has no friend to tell of the fatal catastrophe that had befallen him.
[Austin Reed] Betts: Austin Reed understood the value of telling a story, and it almost felt like he was trying to assert his existence in a different way.
When I was reading his book and I was thinking about it, what is likely to happen without resources, without support, without opportunities, the thing that struck me was--was how it fit into a pattern that was so similar to the lives of people I knew, and Austin Reed, writing his book, I think he was trying to make an account of desires that often don't get documented when you go to prison to be more than whatever the moment was that landed you in prison.
If success begets success, interactions with the system beget more interactions with the system, and I think for Reed, writing his story was a way to shortcut that.
Voice: Reader, be careful and take warning from one who has passed through the iron gates of sorrow and trouble.
Take warning, lest you also come to this place of torment and become the inmate of a dark and gloomy prison.
[Austin Reed] ♪ Narrator: In 1860, Abraham Lincoln was elected president.
The Southern states seceded from the Union, and the nation was plunged into a bloody Civil War over the issue of slavery.
[Gunfire] ♪ As Union and Confederate soldiers fought in the East, another conflict was exploding out West, the Dakota War.
In the summer of 1862 in Minnesota, thousands of Dakota people began to starve.
Along with thousands of other Native Americans, they had been forced off their lands and confined on reservations as the United States expanded across the continent.
Kevin H. Sharp: They were promised that they would be taken care of.
"If you will move to this land, that we believe is no good, "it's not fertile enough for you to grow anything, "and it really doesn't have the wildlife there "so that you can hunt and feed yourselves, "but if you will, nevertheless, move there, then we will clothe you, and we'll feed you," and then they didn't.
The government didn't.
A lot of what was supposed to go to the Native communities was stolen.
♪ Voice: We have no food.
We beg for what little we do get, and then can't get it till our children were dying with hunger.
The traders told the Indians they could eat grass or their own dung.
When men are hungry, they help themselves.
Little Crow.
Narrator: When the food they had been promised failed to arrive, Little Crow led an attack on the Indian agency, defeated the state militia sent after him, and then went on to destroy settlements, kill settlers, and take hostages until a large volunteer army crushed the uprising.
Duthu: Their crime?
From an Indigenous perspective, they were defending their homeland against aggressors because they were defending what had been left to them in these treaties.
Narrator: The surviving settlers demanded that the Dakota warriors who had taken part in the fighting be punished.
The federal government put 392 of them on trial for "murder and other outrages."
303 were found guilty and sentenced to death.
Sharp: They were not given lawyers, and so they didn't get the protections of the Constitution.
So they didn't speak the language, weren't represented, and were tried in cases that lasted 5 to 10 minutes, sentenced to death.
They were literally going to hang 300 people simultaneously.
Word got to President Lincoln, who said, "Wait a minute.
I don't think we can hang 300 people."
Narrator: Lincoln reviewed all of their cases and selected 38 men to be executed, whom he decided were guilty of rape or murder.
[Snare drum playing] On December 26, 1862, 4,000 people made their way to the town of Mankato, Minnesota, to witness the largest mass hanging in American history.
On the specially built scaffold, the condemned men held hands, shouted out their own names, and waited for the drop to fall.
[Drumroll] [Clank, thud] They were buried in a mass grave on the outskirts of town.
Duthu: We often hear that the original crime in the U.S.
was the institution of slavery.
We spend not enough time to understand the dispossession and the robbery of the lands of Indigenous peoples.
And until we have this acknowledgement of how this country was formed, we're gonna make just very timid progress towards what our framers beautifully said in the Constitution, "to form a more perfect union."
♪ [Wind blowing] Narrator: In 1865, the Civil War came to an end.
The South was in ruins.
Some 700,000 Union and Confederate soldiers had died.
4 million enslaved people were now free.
What followed became known as Reconstruction.
Breyer: When the North won and when slavery came to an end, the conditions did not come to an end, but the slavery came to an end.
They passed the 13th, 14th, 15th Amendments.
The 13th Amendment says we are not gonna have slavery in this country.
The 14th Amendment says that "No state" shall deprive a person of "equal protection of the law" nor "deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law."
That was a big change.
And the 15th Amendment says no one will be deprived of the right to vote because of race, because of previous conditions, servitude, slavery.
Elie Mystal: These are the amendments that reconstitutes this country as a free and fair nation.
The 14th Amendment stands out as certainly the most important Amendment to the Constitution because it says very simply that there will be "equal protection under the law."
Nobody in America had said that before, that we were just going to-- that the laws were going to be applied to everybody equally.
So now the state governments and their state laws and their state law enforcement all have to follow the principles of equal protection under the law and due process for everybody in the states.
Stevenson: After Emancipation, you know, Black people who were enslaved did something really remarkable.
They could have said, "We want revenge "against the people who enslaved us.
"We want retribution against the people who enslaved us," but instead, they did this hopeful thing where they say, "You know what?
We're gonna build a better America."
Narrator: To enforce the new amendments and uphold the rule of law, the federal government stationed troops throughout the South.
Black men would now be able to serve on juries and vote.
They would be elected judges, sheriffs, state legislators, Congressmen, and United States senators.
Black people had a measure of protection to go about their lives under the new rules of the Constitution, but they are also experiencing backlash either through direct violence by new terrorist organizations like the Ku Klux Klan, or forms of subterfuge or voter intimidation.
Voice: Armed bands of white men patrolled the country roads to drive back the negroes wandering about.
Dead bodies of murdered negroes were found on and near the highways and by-paths.
A veritable reign of terror prevailed in many parts of the South.
Major General Carl Schurz.
Narrator: Meanwhile, a crime wave was sweeping the entire nation.
Nearly half-a-million Union and Confederate soldiers had returned home carrying the guns they had fought with, and many were having trouble adjusting to life in peacetime.
"Robberies, shooting affairs, and other crimes appear to be frightfully on the increase," a Missouri newspaper reported, with some towns "literally overrun with thieves, burglars, and highway robbers."
[Horse neighing, hoofbeats] On February 13, 1866, in Liberty, Missouri, two men walked up to the counter of the Clay County Savings Association, drew their revolvers, and demanded all the money in the vault.
They made off with $58,072, and as they rode out of town, they fired into the air, killing a bystander.
It was one of the first daylight bank robberies on record.
The men who pulled it off were part of a gang of guerilla soldiers who had fought for the Confederacy.
Voice: It is of no use to shut our eyes to the facts and to pretend that a little thieving is at the bottom of all this.
It is a deeper and more serious evil than that.
These guerillas, in addition to being thieves and robbers and murderers, are rebels.
"Kansas City Journal of Commerce" [May 11th, 1865].
Narrator: One of the former rebels wreaking havoc in the Midwest was a young man from Missouri.
Born and raised in a slave-owning family, he had been shot twice in the war and had taken part in massacres of unarmed Union soldiers and civilians.
He returned from the war unwilling to accept the South's defeat and scornful of the anti-slavery Republicans who now controlled Missouri.
His name was Jesse James.
Along with his older brother Frank, Jesse took up a life of lawlessness-- robbing banks and stagecoaches, killing people who got in his way.
Whenever he was accused of a crime, Jesse wrote to the newspapers.
Voice: A great many say that we, the robbers, deserve hanging.
What have we done to be hung for?
It is true that I shot a little girl, though it was not intentional, and I am very sorry that the child was shot; and if the parents will give me their address through the columns of the "Kansas City Weekly Times," I will send them money to pay her doctor's bill.
Very Respectfully, Jesse W. James.
Narrator: Jesse James sought publicity and fame and was eager to feed the public's fascination with crime and criminals.
He even planned some robberies with an eye to how they would be covered in the press.
Voice: As a great deal has been said in regard to the robbery which occurred at the Kansas City Exposition Grounds, I will give a few lines to the public, as I am one of the party who perpetrated the deed.
It is true, we are robbers, but we always rob in the glare of the day.
We rob the rich and give to the poor.
We are bold robbers, and I am proud of the name, for Alexander the Great was a bold robber, and Julius Caesar and Napoleon Bonaparte.
Please rank me with these.
Very Respectfully, Jesse W. James.
[Camera's flash powder pops] Narrator: Only a handful of photographs were taken of him, and few people knew what Jesse James looked like, but he was recognized while holding up a stagecoach near Lexington, Missouri.
An admiring passenger later told a reporter that if he had to be robbed, it was thrilling to have it done by a first-class artist.
[Horse neighs] McLennan: I think Jesse James found a ready-made audience.
We're talking about the post-Civil War South, a region that had just gone through a completely destructive war that had resulted in the liberation of 4 million people but had also destroyed Southern infrastructure, Southern lives, and Jesse James represented a certain kind of powerful masculinity.
It's very, very appealing that he's robbing the rich.
Even if he's not entirely giving it to the poor, he's nonetheless standing up for certain redistribution that they have not benefited from.
[Sound of gunfire] Narrator: When committing crimes, the James Gang sometimes covered their faces with masks similar to those worn by the Ku Klux Klan, and wherever they went, they made no secret of their anti-Union views.
When the James brothers robbed a bank in Iowa, they easily evaded capture by returning home to Missouri, where the Iowa police had no jurisdiction.
The only federal law enforcement agency was the U.S.
Marshals, but they were stretched thin, so the Iowa bank's owners turned to Allan Pinkerton's National Detective Agency for help.
Voice: The role of a detective is a high and honorable calling.
They must be men of high order of mind and must possess clean, honest, comprehensive understanding, force of will, and vigor of body.
Allan Pinkerton.
Narrator: Allan Pinkerton was an immigrant from Scotland who got his start in law enforcement in Illinois, when he stumbled upon a gang of counterfeiters and helped a local sheriff catch them.
Soon, he opened a "detective agency" and went to work for the railroads.
Pinkerton had also helped runaways escape from slavery and, during the Civil War, ran a "secret service" of undercover agents in the Union Army.
After the war, Pinkerton expanded his agency, opening offices in several cities.
His clients were constantly moving cash, gold, government bonds, and securities by train across state lines through vast expanses of sparsely populated territory-- easy prey for outlaws like the James Gang, who had progressed from robbing banks to holding up trains.
Allan Pinkerton and his operatives, including his sons Robert and William, tried for years to apprehend the James brothers.
After the gang killed two of their men, the Pinkertons vowed revenge.
Voice: I consider Jesse James the worst man, without any exception, in America.
He is utterly devoid of fear and has no more compunction about cold-blooded murder than he has about eating his breakfast.
Robert Pinkerton.
Narrator: In the winter of 1875, Allan Pinkerton learned that Jesse and Frank were staying at their mother's farm in Kearney, Missouri, and dispatched a team of heavily armed men with orders to capture the outlaws and "destroy the house, wipe it from the face of the earth."
[Loud thuds, men shouting] The nighttime raid was a disaster.
Pinkerton's detectives hurled an incendiary device into the house, blowing off the arm of the outlaws' mother and killing their 8-year-old brother.
Jesse and Frank were nowhere to be found.
A few months later, a man who had helped the Pinkertons plan the raid was murdered.
In the face of what he called "a reign of terror... all through Clay County," Allan Pinkerton abandoned any hope of bringing Jesse James to justice.
Voice: They can't stop us from robbing trains; it's our business.
We expect to keep this up all our lives.
If we're gonna be wicked, we might as well make a good job of it.
Jesse W. James.
Narrator: In July of 1881, while robbing a Rock Island Railroad train, the James Gang murdered a conductor and a passenger.
The Governor of Missouri announced a $10,000 reward for each of the brothers-- put up by the railroad's owners.
Less than a year later, on April 3, 1882, a member of his own gang named Robert Ford, eager to collect the reward, shot and killed Jesse James.
♪ Harry McClintock: ♪ And the people held their breath ♪ ♪ When they heard of Jesse's death ♪ ♪ Wondered how he'd came to die ♪ ♪ For the big reward, little Robert Ford ♪ ♪ Shot Jesse James on the sly ♪ Narrator: 2,000 admirers came to Kearney, Missouri, for his funeral.
McClintock: ♪ Jesse was a man, a friend to the poor ♪ ♪ He'd never see a man suffer pain ♪ ♪ But with his brother Frank ♪ ♪ He robbed the Springfield Bank ♪ ♪ And stopped the Glendale train ♪ Smith: There have been outlaw ballads and criminal narratives going back hundreds and hundreds of years.
It's the story of the romantic, heroic, rebellious outsider, who is making his own way, often showing up the rich snobs, often showing up the stuffy religious authorities, and exercising his own kind of wild freedom.
Betts: I grew up believing that he was a hero.
There was something that was alluring about being an outlaw.
It was something-- it was cool about, like, when you watched the Westerns and they squared off, and it was take 10 paces.
'Cause it felt like, actually, this was justice in real time, but this is the thing about Jesse James.
He's somebody that you should not idolize.
He's somebody who should force you to question how it came to be that--that we were seduced by the allure of what a man can do with violence.
McClintock: ♪ But they laid Jesse James in his grave ♪ [Singers humming] Voice: You say you have emancipated us.
You have; and I thank you for it.
You say you have enfranchised us.
You have; and I thank you for it.
But when you turned us loose, you gave us no acres: you turned us loose to the sky, to the storm, to the whirlwind, and, worst of all, you turned us loose to the wrath of our infuriated masters.
Frederick Douglass.
Narrator: In the late 1870s, after a series of political compromises and economic crises, the federal government withdrew most of its troops from the South.
Just a decade after it had begun, Reconstruction was over.
♪ New Jim Crow laws segregated every aspect of Southern life, and the rights Black Americans had begun to enjoy were steadily taken away.
To keep Black people from voting, holding public office, or serving on juries, Southern states enacted poll taxes and literacy tests.
Talitha LeFlouria: Just because the 14th Amendment guaranteed citizenship to Black people didn't mean that white people were gonna respect that federal amendment.
Just because the 15th Amendment guaranteed Black men the right to vote, it didn't protect them when white supremacists hung them for exercising that right to vote.
Just because slavery was abolished through the 13th Amendment didn't mean that Black people would end up essentially being re-enslaved through a loophole in that same amendment.
Narrator: The 13th Amendment had abolished slavery and involuntary servitude, "except as a punishment for crime."
Congress had included the exception to protect the system of contract prison labor that had begun at Auburn and was essential to prisons all over the country.
If people who had committed crimes could no longer be forced to work, the prisons would no longer have a chance of making money, let alone breaking even.
McLennan: Had the 13th Amendment simply prohibited slavery and involuntary servitude without any kind of exception, those Northern prisons containing tens of thousands of people would have found themselves unconstitutional, so the 13th Amendment had to include an exemption clause, and it was backward-looking in that regard.
[Tool thuds] The 13th Amendment's also forward-looking.
It is a permission note.
Narrator: The 13th Amendment gave white Southerners a legal way to force African Americans back into involuntary servitude simply by convicting them of a crime.
Sherrilyn Ifill: Black people can be arrested simply for being on the street without papers showing who they are employed by and that if they are not employed by a white person, they can be taken into prison, where they can then be leased by plantation owners, and what Southern jurisdictions do is when they decide that they need more labor, they change the law and they create harsher penalties for pig stealing, for stealing clothes off of a line, for stealing coins off of a counter in the store.
All of these are infractions that can pull you into the system.
LeFlouria: And so every Southern state in America incorporates what was called "the convict lease system," and what this system entailed was Southern states hiring out prisoners with felony convictions to private contractors for a fee, and they would take them to work in factories, they would take them to work building railroads, they would take them to work in mines.
There was no oversight, there was no protection, there was no control.
Ifill: Many of them are children.
Some are arrested when they are 7 or 8 years old and then leased out.
People are working in hip-deep water, digging trenches.
They're asked to drain malarial swamps.
They're held in conditions that have been called worse than slavery.
Voice: I wish I could show you our condition clearly.
I have been marked from the lash.
Have worked when not-able.
Have looked death in the face, have worked hungry, thirsty, half clothed.
Oh, how we suffered.
Our cots was filled with filth and vermin in the extreme.
We would leave the cells at 3:00 a.m.
and return at 8:00 p.m., going the distance of 3 miles through rain and snow.
We go to cell wet, go to bed wet, and arise wet the following morning, and every guard knocking, beating, yelling.
And every day some one of us were carried to our last resting, the grave.
[Ezekiel Archey and Ambrose Haskins] Bessie Jones: ♪ This old hammer ♪ [Clang] ♪ Killed John Henry ♪ [Clang] ♪ Laid him low ♪ [Clang] ♪ Laid him low... ♪ Narrator: One business that profited from convict leasing was the C.R.
Mason Company, which was hired by the Chesapeake and Ohio Railroad to drill a mile-long tunnel through a mountain in West Virginia.
To do it, the company leased hundreds of young men serving time in the Virginia State Penitentiary.
One of them was a 5'1" 19-year-old Black man from Elizabeth City, New Jersey, who had been sentenced to 10 years' hard labor for "housebreak and larceny": John William Henry.
Jones: ♪ Killed John Henry ♪ [Heavy machinery clanking] Narrator: Alongside a new invention, the steam drill, John Henry and the other men hammered and hacked into the slate and sandstone beneath the mountain and hauled away rocks and debris.
It was dangerous work.
Many men died in accidents or of malnutrition or disease.
Some tried to escape and were killed by guards, but most died gulping for air, their lungs fatally damaged by the microscopic shards of rock they had inhaled.
Of the 200 men who worked on the tunnel, 100 died.
The C.R.
Mason Company delivered their nameless corpses back to the penitentiary, where they were buried in the sand outside the walls.
John Henry was almost certainly one of them.
Survivors began to tell the story of a "steel drivin' man," who had raced a steam engine, and died "with a hammer in his hand."
In time, John Henry would become an American folk hero, celebrated in story and song for his superhuman strength, but the truth about his incarceration and the way he died would be forgotten.
[Bruce Springsteen's "John Henry" playing] ♪ Springsteen: 1, 2, hey!
♪ Well, John Henry told his captain ♪ ♪ "Lord, a man ain't nothing but a man" ♪ ♪ "Before I let that steam drill beat me down" ♪ ♪ "I'm gonna die with a hammer in my hand, Lord, Lord" ♪ ♪ "Die with a hammer in my hand" ♪ Play it, Soozie!
♪ Betts: This is the most profound absurdity that I've ever, like, learned in my life, that John Henry was locked up for, like, a petty theft, he died of some disease he got from the work that they made him do.
He didn't die racing a steam engine.
I mean, that ruined me in the sense that he is not racing a steam engine.
He is racing American absurdity, and that is what he lost to, but that's what American history does to you.
It takes a fact that should make you weep and turns it into some war cry.
Like, I am not racing any steam engines, you know what I mean?
I--I want to ask real questions about the way in which we dehumanize people and we place them in situations where thriving is not even a possibility, and then we want to act as if their story should inspire us.
He has been turning over in his grave for years.
I can't believe that I lived, like, decades without knowing the truth of that story.
♪ Narrator: In the 100 years since the nation had been founded, Americans had created the world's first penitentiary system, established police forces in nearly every city, abolished slavery, and conquered the continent.
In the decades to come, as the United States experienced an unprecedented surge in immigration and an ever-widening gap between rich and poor, new forms of crime and new forms of punishment would emerge.
At the same time, a new generation of reformers would expose the cruelty, corruption, and prejudice that could be found in every part of the criminal justice system.
♪ Announcer: Next time on "Crime and Punishment in America"... Timothy Gilfoyle: By the 1860s, there are 5,000 to 15,000 children living on the streets of New York.
Reginald Dwayne Betts: They're living in environments with intense emotional challenges.
Heather Ann Thompson: This question of "Who is prison for?"
"Who is it okay to see locked up?"
Sherrilyn Ifill: Does a Black man have the right to defend his home?
Voice: I opened the door and saw the mob.
[Dr.
Ossian Sweet] Announcer: When "Crime and Punishment in America" continues next time.
Announcer: Scan this QR code with your smart device to dive deeper into the story of "Crime and Punishment in America" with interactives, classroom materials, and more.
Announcer: The "Crime and Punishment in America" DVD is available online and in stores.
The series is also available with PBS Passport and on Amazon Prime Video.
The digital companion soundtrack is also available online.
♪ ♪ Announcer: Major funding for "Crime and Punishment in America" was provided by... The Atlantic Philanthropies, Emerson Collective, The Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, and the Park Foundation.
Major funding was also provided by the following members of The Better Angels Society: The Fullerton Family Charitable Fund, The Just Trust for Education, Allan and Shelley Holt, The Tow Foundation, and the Sozosei Foundation.
Additional support was provided by the National Endowment for the Humanities, The Arthur Vining Davis Foundations, and by The Better Angels Society members: John and Catherine Debs, Timothy Fazio, Lise Strickler and Mark Gallogly, the Laurie M. Tisch Illumination Fund, and these additional funders.
"Crime and Punishment in America" was made possible, in part, by contributions to your PBS station from Viewers Like You.
Thank you.
America Creates the World’s First Penitentiary
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep1 | 8m 30s | The Founding Father Benjamin Rush offers a new form of punishment: the world's first penitentiary. (8m 30s)
Austin Reed Details His Experiences in Auburn Prison
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep1 | 9m 40s | Austin Reed recounts his experiences over two decades of being incarcerated in Auburn Prison. (9m 40s)
Elam Lynds Reforms the Auburn Prison System
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep1 | 2m 21s | The new head guard at Auburn Prison establishes a new strict regimen of efficiency and order. (2m 21s)
The House of Refuge and Juvenile Detention
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep1 | 3m 58s | The House of Refuge is the nation's first institution for the reformation of juvenile delinquents. (3m 58s)
The Largest Mass Hanging in American History
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep1 | 4m 26s | President Abraham Lincoln sentences 38 Native Americans to death for attacks against settlers. (4m 26s)
Levi Ames and the Spectacle of Public Execution
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep1 | 2m 45s | There has always been a fascination with those that commit crimes and how they're punished for them. (2m 45s)
The Myths and Fascination with the Outlaw Jesse James
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep1 | 13m 42s | During the Reconstruction Era, an outlaw captures the public's attention: Jesse James. (13m 42s)
What Does It Mean to be Accountable?
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep1 | 10m 11s | When a crime is committed, should we look to punish or to move forward toward healing? (10m 11s)
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipSupport for PBS provided by:
Episodes presented in 4K UHD on supported devices. Major funding for CRIME AND PUNISHMENT IN AMERICA was provided by The Atlantic Philanthropies, Emerson Collective, The Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, and...
























